r/HomeServer • u/sphericalcube_ • 3h ago
Normal noises for a brand new HDD to be making?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Hi everyone. Just starting my journey into the land of building a custom home server.
I have a server machine with an SSD, but I wanted to give it a lot more storage and have that storage be decoupled from the main machine, so a hard drive DAS was the natural choice. The setup right now is a single, brand new WD Red Plus 10TB HDD (WD100EFGX) inside a Terramaster D4-320 hooked up to the server machine via USB. Both purchased from Amazon.
The attached video is a couple clips stitched together. When these clips were recorded, Immich was indexing a bunch of photos I had loaded onto the drive yesterday. The video shows a couple of pretty long, continuous, loud seeking noises. Now, it’s not fully representative of what was happening. These sounds came and went during the indexing job. However, they were always long streaks (5-15 sec) of this noise.
I’m well aware that hard drives make some mechanical noise as they read and write, but the loudness of the sounds this one is making seems excessive. I'm not sure how well it will come across in the video, but the sound is pretty loud here in the room. I don’t remember my last PC with a hard drive ever being this loud, although that was probably 5+ years ago now, so my memory might just be failing me.
Is this a normal amount of noise for a brand new HDD to make, or is it damaged and I should exchange it?

