r/BSTsquishmallow • • May 08 '26

Some Selling Reminders and Expectations

26 Upvotes

Hello everyone!!

Thank you for your continued interest and engagement in this sub. We hope you have been able to conduct good transactions.

We wanted to step in here and just post a few reminders for selling as we've had a few cases here and there. I know that several of you are new here and some of you might be new to selling even if you are not new here. Here are some guidelines you are REQUIRED to follow based on our rules.

  1. Your post must have majority squishmallows. It's ok if you throw in a few non-squish plushes to sell but this is a squishmallow sub and your posts should be primarily squish.
  2. You may not post negative content about resellers or other users on the sub. Please approach us with concerns and we can address things there. This is a sub for postitivity and kindness.
  3. Your prices must be within general community expectations. We do not support resellers (defined as those who buy squish just to resell them at a severely inflated price). In general, $1 per inch in size (~$0.40 per cm) is a great start but you as the seller have a right to charge more depending on the squish. If your prices aren't fair, people won't buy and you'll get negative feedback.

Now, some other expectations. Consider these things you pretty much should always do but we don't have official rules for.

  1. List your prices in the post or comments. People are more likely to buy or reach out to you if you disclose your prices directly in the post.
  2. We try to promote the first come, first serve idea. You as the seller to have the final right to determine what "first" means (first person to DM, first person to pay, first person to comment, etc.) but you should clearly communicate when a squish is "on hold". Be prepared to have a list of who to contact next if the first person falls through.
  3. Include your reddit username on a sticky note in your pictures. This helps establish trust that you didn't steal photos and that you actually have the squish you say you do. Be prepared to send more photos over DM if a buyer asks (and try to include your username in those photos as well).
  4. Many sellers charge for shipping. This is ok and expected. However, as a seller make sure to say that buyers are responsible for shipping in the post. Be prepared to create a shipping estimate to certain zip codes/areas if asked (https://postcalc.usps.com/). However, your final total charged to the buyer should be the actual cost (send receipts of shipping charge if necessary). AVOID as much as you can asking for more money after the buyer has already paid. This looks very much like scam behavior and makes buyers very worries.
  5. Once a squish has sold, clearly communicate the tracking number and when you expect to ship it out. It is ok to ship out multiple orders in bulk and wait a day or two but you should ship quickly and communicate each step of the process.

If you as a seller are unable to handle these expectations or to handle many orders at once, only post a few squish at a time. These guidelines and criteria above are what we use when investigating complaints or scam alerts. The more you follow the better all our experiences will be!

Thank you all. Let us know if you have questions or if you think there are any errors here (totally could be, had a long day today!). Happy squishing!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 13h ago

bst (from usa) NWT Bigfoots UFS

Post image
8 Upvotes

Venmo for payment, buyer pays shipping. Comment or message which ones youre interested in for price. Thanks!
Zozo Fuzzamallow 16”, Evita Fuzzamallow 16”, Buna 12”, Cow Benny 12”, Brina 12”, fuzzy belly diva 8”, Sheba 8”, MallowMoods chase, MallowMoods erm, MallowMoods Wallis, MallowMoods jt


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 1d ago

bst (from usa) Are these worth anything? Or should I just donate?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Cleaning out my plushies and just don’t love these like I used to… any suggestions on possible pricings or donation/charity locations in the Dallas/Fort Worth TX area is appreciated!

I’ve mainly been struggling to find comps for the 12” Mila/ Heather/ carol group online and the pink butterfly doesn’t have a tag but, I remember she came out of an orange? Egg?🤷 if that helps any

Thank you☺️

(Big green Carol is from the deer, gnome, Santa release)


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 1d ago

bst (from usa) SELLING! Pricing in desc. US only! Need gone ASAP!

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Pricing: $1 per inch + buyer pays for shipping(offers accepted though!)

Payment options will be discussed in DMs.

DM if interested, have questions, or if you want close up photos. I have tags for most but not all. Some tags are still attached.

Also LOOKING FOR PINEAPPLES. Willing to trade!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 1d ago

bst (from usa) UFS Buyer Pays Shipping. Willing To Trade For ISOs (2nd photo)

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 3d ago

bst (from other country) Anyone selling from the Philippines? 🇵🇭

Post image
4 Upvotes

I'm looking for Filipino sellers cause my bday is coming up and the stores don't sell new stuff or anything I'm interested on 🤧

I'm not looking to buy instantly, just wondering if there are any sellers active 🥳

(P.S. this is my collection and I don't intend to sell)


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 4d ago

bst (from usa) Looking to buy Cannon the Candy Corn 16" (non-shiny)

3 Upvotes

Hello, I'm looking for that particular Squishmallow if anyone has it for sale! Doesn't need the tag, but should be clean at least.


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 5d ago

bst (from usa) Prices below but atp I’ll accept anything | Need gone ASAP | US Only

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

10-12 inch $10
4-8 inch $5
3 inch and under $3


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 4d ago

iso / diso ❤︎ Looking to sell some of my squish!

2 Upvotes

Question! Where do you guys post to sell your squishmallows? I used to collect them and have lots, but don’t have room for most of them anymore and want to downsize. Thank you in advance!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 5d ago

bst (from usa) Up for sale! (:

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 5d ago

iso / diso ❤︎ DISO!

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I’m particular about having the tag though! 😭


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 6d ago

bst (from usa) Squish for Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 8d ago

bst (from usa) Squish for sale

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 9d ago

bst (from usa) UFS/UFT! (: iso is last photo

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Also UFT for my Amazon wish list!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 9d ago

bst (from usa) Continuing my big Bigfoot sale! Read my description please 🩷

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I’m continuing to keep posting & selling all my Bigfoots. B1G1 50% off offer still stands! Please comment or message me with any questions, not all are still available so feel free to ask which ones I have or if you have any specific ones you’re looking for!

I use pirate ship to ship & take both Venmo G&S & PayPal G&S! I can send photos of any at anytime so feel free to ask!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 9d ago

bst (from usa) Squishmallow for Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

For sale! Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 9d ago

bst (from usa) Squishmallows for sale

2 Upvotes

Hi! I have a mix of squishmallows that I am trying to sell. I wanted to see if anyone was interested in buying anything at all or in search of anything specific before I post a picture of all of them! Thanks 😊


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 9d ago

bst (from usa) christmas (i believe 5 inch) up for trade! i like food-related squishmallows

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 10d ago

bst (from usa) Updated squish sale! Prices Below! US Only

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

4.5-8 inch squish are $5 each
10-14 inch squish are $10 each
4 inch and smaller $3 each
If you see any of the same squish in multiple pics its bc I took these pics over multiple days, I only have one of each squish shown. I am open to bundles and offers!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 11d ago

iso / diso ❤︎ Looking to trade for my Halloween Isos listed below

Post image
7 Upvotes

Hey friends. Its been a while since ive done a trade and id love to see if anyone had any of my Halloween isos up for trade and would like to trade with me. My iso list is in the photo below. If you have any of these up for trade and would like to see my trades, please leave a comment below with who you have. I have tons of new and old Squishmallows and plush up for trade and would love to work something out. I am also willing to trade internationally if you do have my isos and would be interested. As always, thanks for looking and have a great day!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 11d ago

bst (from usa) trade: looking for food-related micromallow

Post image
11 Upvotes

i have this little guy to trade if anyone’s interested! thanks


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 12d ago

bst (from usa) Selling an error Fuecoco

Post image
9 Upvotes

Gf picked him up cause he was cute but noticed the error so just seeing if anyone is interested :)


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 13d ago

bst (from usa) Clips for sale

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Hi all, anyone looking for clips. I have these duplicates and looking to sell as a bundle for $22+shipping.

Full disclosure, Maggie and Maui had a smudge (second pic) that I used a Tide pen to remove, and Swerl has their tag but it's separated which is why she's in a ziploc.


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 13d ago

bst (from usa) Mallowmees

Post image
13 Upvotes

$16 each shipped that’s retail plus shipping


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 13d ago

bst (from usa) All up for sale! (:

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes