r/PoliticalOpinions • u/K0rek • 4h ago
Western pro-Palestinian protests should focus much more on Hamas, but they're currently focusing almost entirely on Israel, which I think sends a certain message and reflects a certain mindset
I've noticed that pro-Palestine protests focus almost entirely on Israel's government and military, and I rarely see signs or chants criticizing Hamas, even though Hamas governs Gaza and is also partly responsible for the suffering of people there.
Gaza hasn't had an election since 2006, and Freedom House describes Hamas as governing in an authoritarian manner and suppressing criticism of its rule. When Gazans protested high taxes and living costs in 2019, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch documented Hamas beating, arresting, and torturing protesters and journalists. In 2025, Amnesty again reported that Hamas threatened and beat Gazans who protested against its rule and the war. Meanwhile, Hamas has heavily taxed Gazans and spent huge resources on tunnels and weapons, while its top leaders lived comfortably abroad in Qatar.
I understand the usual argument: Western protesters target Israel because their own governments support Israel, not Hamas. But if the goal is a better life for Palestinians, then the group that rules them, suppresses their dissent, and tortures their protesters can't be left out of the picture. Gazans themselves have protested against Hamas at real personal risk. Western protesters face no such risk, yet they stay silent about it.
That silence sends a message, whether intended or not: that Hamas's role in Palestinian suffering doesn't matter, or that criticizing it is off limits. It also makes it easier for critics to dismiss the whole movement as being against Israel rather than for Palestinians. Adding even basic criticism of Hamas would make the protests more consistent, more credible, and closer to what many Gazans themselves have been saying.