My dad sadly passed away earlier this year, aged 70, leaving a pension worth approximately £150,000 with Standard Life.
In July 2024, he formally nominated my two young daughters (his granddaughters) as the sole beneficiaries, allocating 50% to each.
I also have WhatsApp messages showing that he discussed the nomination with me, asked for their dates of birth and subsequently sent me a screenshot confirming he'd nominated them both.
My dad also had a valid will, written before his pension nomination, which left his estate equally between me, my sister and his long-term partner.
His will remained unchanged when he passed away.
Standard Life has explained that although my daughters are the nominated beneficiaries, the nomination isn't legally binding and the scheme administrators have discretion over who receives the pension.
They are therefore contacting other potential beneficiaries.
My dad's partner of approximately 13 years has now confirmed that she wishes to be considered for a share of the pension, despite already being entitled to one-third of his estate under his will.
They weren't married, had no children together and, as far as I'm aware, maintained separate households and finances. She had her own council tenancy throughout their relationship.
They also separated for prolonged periods in 2020 and 2024, although they had reconciled by the time my dad passed away.
I'm not aware of any ongoing financial dependency between them, although I appreciate I don't know the full details of their private finances.
My dad made a clear distinction between his estate and his pension. He provided for his partner through his will and subsequently chose to nominate his granddaughters for the pension.
I'm worried Standard Life could award his partner a share, reducing what my daughters receive.
I understand that his partner is entitled to ask to be considered and that Standard Life must follow its scheme rules.
My questions are:
- Has anyone experienced a pension provider departing from a clear beneficiary nomination, particularly where an unmarried partner was involved?
- How much weight do pension administrators generally give to the deceased's nomination compared with a surviving partner's circumstances?
- Does the fact that my dad made his pension nomination after writing his will, which separately provided for his partner, strengthen my daughters' position?
- Would it be recommended to get a solicitor involved at any point?
- Basically, what are the chances that my dads partners claim will be successful and what percentage would she be looking at getting.
I would have to borrow money to pay for legal representation, so I'm reluctant to do that unless it could genuinely make a difference.
Thanks in advance.