r/classicalmusic • • 23h ago

Discussion Will I be ready for a conservatory?

2 Upvotes

I’m applying for piano the next few months and I’m probably overthinking myself into a hole, but:

I’m very worried I will end up as a dropout or careerless.

I should’ve picked bassoon—everybody needs a bassoonist

I struggle with my mental health greatly and I only started at 12 so there’s concern about gaps in my technique. Also, it takes me FOREVER to learn music. However, I consistently place in reputable international competitions despite my lack of technique.

I adore the piano, it’s all I think about everyday and I couldn’t imagine doing anything else, but I want to be realistic. I don’t expect to get into Julliard or anything, but I’m constantly debating whether I should pick a safer career. My goal is to get my DMA, win a major competition, and become a professor.

Am I aiming too high? My only source of confidence is the fact that I have competitions out the wazoo, even then I’m not as confident as I’d like to be.

Any advice?


r/classicalmusic • • 10h ago

what is the difference between classical and film score music?

4 Upvotes

hello,

i grew up in a household where classical was always playing. i wish i had an encyclopedic knowledge of it like many, but despite loving it so much as i do, i guess i'm ultimately a casual enjoyer (though the emotions it elicits certainly aren't casual).

then some years later, i got really into film score music.

actually, i'm not even really sure what genre it might be which encapsulates this music i'm talking about, but "film score" seems to be most fitting, even if some of the artists haven't been featured in films afaik (but several have, prominently at that).

joep beving, olafur arnalds, nils frahm, max richter, johann johannsson, etc. and of course then the more 'famous' names; zimmer, williams, morricone, and so on.

after first asking myself this question before posting here, if pressed to answer, my casual observation is such that much of the film score music certainly accomplishes the feat of tugging at your heartstrings, stirring up emotions, conjuring up imagery, but ultimately doesn't seem as deep, complex, evolving- film music seems to rely much more on repetition (themes), while much classical seems to move along more.

i don't want to take anything away from film music as, truly, some of my most emotive moments as a listener throughout my lifetime have been a result of scores i've heard... that depth and emotion cannot be faked... or can it, and is that kind of the point maybe even? i don't know, i'm just being silly, thinking out loud here.

i'd love to hear more from you much more knowledgable lot about the distinction(s) and/or if maybe the lines are actually much more blurred than i think, perhaps one genre veering into the next even... i could see that being the case too.

i really don't wish to diminish the efforts of any of those musicians/composers i've cited, because lots from their catalogue is truly genre-defining, culture-shaping, and generally very epic, but it somehow feels 'shallow' compared to a lot of classical- i don't know how else to describe my feeling. kind of like cola vs diet cola (or perhaps zero cola is more apt).


r/classicalmusic • • 7h ago

Anyone else want Metallica and the SF Symphony to reunite for S&M3?

0 Upvotes

I was at the Metallica Sphere show in Las Vegas, and it was absolutely epic. It got me thinking about how incredible it would be to experience another S&M show.

The original S&M in 1999 and S&M2 at Chase Center in 2019 were something special. With Metallica's Bay Area roots, bringing them back together with the San Francisco Symphony for S&M3 feels like a no-brainer.

I started a petition to see if we can get enough fans behind the idea to catch Metallica and the Symphony's attention.

Would you want to see S&M3 happen? 🤘

Sign the petition here: Change.org/Metallica_SM3


r/classicalmusic • • 6h ago

Discussion Possibly the worst Beethoven Eroica I have ever heard in the a long time.

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is an absolute abomination which is Christian Thielemann levels of bad. If anyone want to hear this abomination of a recording for themselves Here it is: Bruno Walter Beethoven 3.

It's an absolute snoozefest characterized by ploddingly slow tempos, zero energy or momentum, and none of that essential revolutionary character this symphony demands.

  • First movement: Bottom line: It's too slow. in fact ahe movements 1, 2, 4 are all played way too slow. As a results it just sounds so flat footed and absolutely devoid of energy. Listen to the development section which is around letter G ish(which is about 5 minutes in the recording), and compare it to Gielen or Kleiber.
  • Second Movement: What an absolute slog. Beethoven was trying to create impression of a "military funeral", and the motif of triplet 32nds are in fact an imitation of a drum roll. It should NOT give the impression of a Bruckner slow movement. Also we have given a glimpse of what yet to come in the form of Walter not understanding detached how string playing works. 2 bars before A in the score(which is 1 minute into the recording, you just only hear legato, when the 32nds are marked with dots by Beethoven
  • Third movement: The strings sounded like chicken scratch in the beginning and you could just barely hear the real notes, there is absolutely no core in the sound. The 3 horns in the trio might as well have never been there. I have never heard the trio section be played so spineless and anemically.
  • Finale: Ploddingly slow tempo that sucks all the juice out of it. Walter just couldn’t let the strings in the orchestra play a proper staccato for some reason. Then later on, the flute solo completely drowned out in the sea of muddled strings, and then comes the most anemic Letter C (G minor section) I have ever heard anyone play. (its marked sempre forte and staccato for christ sake!) In the Coda at the end, the orchestra gets really out of sync in the Presto at the end.

In order for us to understand what good performance of the Eroica sounds like, we can reference these recordings and then compare to the Walter, These are all good performances imo.

Michael Gielen (Great all-around probably my favourite overall)

Erich Kleiber (2nd movement too slow though, others are great)

Ivan Fischer (If you prefer slower tempos)


r/classicalmusic • • 7h ago

Recommendation Request Most epic/grand openings to lesser known pieces?

1 Upvotes

sorry to use the word epic unironically, i hate it 99% of the time but in certain contexts like this it kinda does describe what type of opening im talking about, pieces with a lot of grandeur or strong affect

but im looking for lesser known pieces, ones that are not mentioned as often as the ones on this list:

bach st john passion - like wow. the matthew passion is also great but i think the st john is a lot more accessible in its overt drama

ravel daphnis et chloe - the start from nothing with the soft choir and then the building to the huge G major over B is so good and you just KNOW its going to be a whole adventure

handel messiah - tbh i just have a thing for works with a nice overture with the dramatic dotted rhythm intro to a fast fugato. like bach bwv 826 and 831 and the orchestral suites, theyre always exciting

mozart requiem - yes

i swear if someone unironically says rach 2. or literally anything by him for that matter like hes so corny


r/classicalmusic • • 5h ago

How impactful is classical music on punk rock?

13 Upvotes

If you're the kind of weirdo who thinks classical music would never sully itself with any kind of popular culture... well, it's probably because you don't hear much classical music.

One only has to hear movie and video game soundtracks to appreciate how classical music impacts modern culture.

But what about something as abrasive and low brow as punk rock?

Well, one day, I was listening to the Velvet Underground. "The Black Angel's Death Song" came on. And my immediate thought was, "Wait a minute. This sounds more like an experimental classical song than a rock song."

Turns out I was right.

This particular song was deeply influenced by the classical composer La Monte Young. One only has to hear Young's composition "The Second Dream of the High-Tension Line Stepdown Transformer" to see the connection. And if that doesn't convince you, VU member John Cale performed in Young's Theatre of Eternal Music before joining the Velvet Underground.

Consequently, La Monte Young is probably the most consequential composer in any genre upon the evolution of punk rock since his signature drones, sustained tones, dissonance, and repetition can still be heard in the genre now.

So is La Monte Young just a one-off, a rare classical guy who accidentally impacted the most unclassical of rock music?

Well, no. There's another source of classical, and that's through Karlheinz Stockhausen. He was an early experimenter who pioneered tape manipulation, feedback, and electronically generated sound.

Almost every punk band that engaged with synths, such as Cabaret Voltaire, were impacted by Stockhausen. Now some people might object and call Cabaret Voltaire post-punk rather than punk. But since they formed in 1973, if anything, they are a pre-punk band who had a seminal influence on punk itself, and you can hear that on their compilation "1974-1976".

Finally, the classical composers who are the most blatantly punk in ethos: Steve Reich and Philip Glass. These composers were an inspiration to artists as diverse as Brian Eno and David Byrne. But their most direct connection is with another classical composer, Glenn Branca. You see, Branca was a full participant in the seminal no wave scene, and it was Branca who imported Reich and Glass's minimalist techniques that became essential to bands like Sonic Youth.

Indeed, Thurston Moore and Lee Ranaldo of Sonic Youth played in his guitar ensembles, as did musicians associated with Swans.

So while at first glance it seems punk rock has nothing to do with classical music, it seems to have everything to do with classical music.

But what's your opinion?


r/classicalmusic • • 14h ago

Music Looking for a piece of music in every single key

0 Upvotes

Is there a single piece of music that tonicizes every major and minor key in the Western tradition that isn’t an exercise? By this I mean:

— It is continuous (not split over several acts or movements)

— Includes all major and minor keys (C major, C minor, C# minor, D-flat major, etc. all the way up to B major and minor)

— These must be tonicised with a perfect authentic cadential progression (eg. ii-V-I) with the melodic/upper note being the first degree of the scale.


r/classicalmusic • • 2h ago

Music Beethoven's Für Elise as a color timeline, where each bar shows how bright the sound is at that moment

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/classicalmusic • • 9h ago

Recommendation Request IYO how does this Eroica stack up?

Post image
13 Upvotes

I came across a nice-looking copy of this 200g LP and have since learned that there are several re-issues of this recording. How does this interpretation stack up against, say, one of the other "classic" recordings like Klemperer? Any thoughts on the recording itself? Remastered in 2002 with all tube electronics, apparently.


r/classicalmusic • • 15h ago

My Composition My sister just released her new harp performance video – Sabin Pautza's "From Dear Dreams, Poems..."

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone! My sister, Evelina Andrieș, has been pouring her heart into the harp for a long time, and she just uploaded a beautiful new solo performance on YouTube.

She's playing “From Dear Dreams, Poems...” by Sabin Pautza in such a lovely, warm setting. I would love to surprise her with a few more views and some nice comments from fellow music lovers.

If you have a few minutes, give it a listen here:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7UGmteNq4k

Thank you so much! 🎵✨


r/classicalmusic • • 7h ago

Why does Andris Nelsons get so much hate? What am I missing?

21 Upvotes

I see Nelsons conduct the Boston Symphony regularly, and I usually leave having thoroughly enjoyed myself. But when I read discussions of his recordings, his Beethoven is supposedly boring, his Bruckner too slow, and his Mahler dull and lifeless. You’d think his entire discography should come with a warning: “Do not listen while operating heavy machinery."

I know David Hurwitz is very critical of Nelsons, and I wonder whether that repeated criticism has influenced people’s perceptions. Does hearing the same verdict often enough start to shape what we expect before the orchestra plays a note?

The reaction to the recently released Mahler box set is what prompted this post. I’ve seen some remarkably hostile comments, including from people who don’t seem to have listened to it yet. Reviewing a Mahler cycle without listening certainly saves time, but I feel we may be skipping an important step. I’ve listened to Symphonies 1, 2, and 3 so far, and I like them very much. But I’m not a musician, just someone who loves listening to music.

Different tastes make perfect sense to me. It’s the intensity of the hostility that puzzles me.

What am I missing? Have I been enjoying Mahler without the appropriate permit?


r/classicalmusic • • 6h ago

Recommendation Request Contemporary classical music recs?

5 Upvotes

I have been enjoying listening to Forrest Morning by Øyvind Torvund. Are there any more similar pieces that I might like?


r/classicalmusic • • 11h ago

Music Avante-Garde Baroque

20 Upvotes

Does anyone have any recommendations for avante-garde Baroque. Strange and atonal is a plus. Basically pieces that sound like they're ahead of their time or still ahead of their time. Thanks!


r/classicalmusic • • 13h ago

Music Music / Classical

Thumbnail
nixamp.com
0 Upvotes

Its ai but I'm automatically generating it -- sorry for the haters out there.


r/classicalmusic • • 14h ago

Discussion Why are they selling beethoven's fire crackers in india?!

Post image
92 Upvotes

I wonder how it will sound when it gets exploded


r/classicalmusic • • 18h ago

Essential classical music guide books

8 Upvotes

I'm a relative newbie wanting to build a personal cd collection of classical music. Which guide books do you refer to or which ones do you recommend?? A book from NPR or NYT or something else?? Or do you refer to someone on the net like Hurwitz on YouTube?

I am finding it tricky as many CDs / recordings aren't available anymore or they are reissued or repackaged. Also any tips on building on a budget??

Are box sets a good way to go or is it better to just shoot for reference recordings?? Lastly does it make sense to listen explore through composer or through performer or time period /genre?? Many thanks in advance for your input in this sprawling and occasionally bewildering landscape!


r/classicalmusic • • 4h ago

If you could only keep composers from one letter of the alphabet?

62 Upvotes

For me it’d have to be S.

Saint Saens
Schoenberg
Schubert
Schumann
Scriabin
Shostakovich
Sibelius
Smetana
R Strauss
Stravinsky

I could live with that list! Plenty of great Romanticism and Modernism. Scriabin if I wanna get freaky. Schoenberg if I wanna lose my mind…


r/classicalmusic • • 5h ago

Which pieces do you keep listening to again and again?

68 Upvotes

Which pieces do you consider "addictive"?

For me, Brahms Symphony N. 4. I keep coming back to it incredibly frecuently. Even though I know it since decades, I still find new things there.

Also Dvorak Symphony Nr 7 and 8.


r/classicalmusic • • 1h ago

American Soprano Judith Blegen Has Passed, what a pure and radiant voice she possessed. Her Dulcissime from Orff's Carmina Burana is phenomenal. I don't know of a better take.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
• Upvotes

r/classicalmusic • • 11h ago

Domenico Scarlatti (1685-1757): Three Harpsichord Sonatas, Parma II, 6-8

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/classicalmusic • • 22h ago

What's a good first piano concerto?

3 Upvotes

I've been looking at a few but I'm not sure which ones would be within my ability to learn in the span of a year. If any of y'all know of any that would suit me or someone new to concerti, please do tell!

Some pieces I've played so far:

  • Candlelight Carol - John Rutter (This one's a very contemporary, but if you don't want to go give it a listen, the gist is that it has a lot of voices/melodies at the same time and you have to be expressive.)
  • Wedding Day at Trouldhodgen - Grieg
  • Sonata No. 1 in F Minor, Op. 2 No. 1 (4th movement) - Beethoven
  • Polonaise in A Major (Military), Op. 40 No. 1 - Chopin
  • Rhapsody in B minor Op. 79 No. 1 - Brahms

Some of the concerti I've been looking at:

  • Saint-Saens No. 2
  • Mendelssohn No. 1
  • Shostakovich No. 2 (This one's probably my least favorite though.)
  • Robert Muczynski — Piano Concerto No. 1 (This one is kinda hip. Would it be good to do a more contemporary concerto for my first one? or should I just stick to a baroque/classical/romantic era one?)

Are these concerti too hard? Are there any other beautiful or dramatic ones that are suitable for someone of my level?


r/classicalmusic • • 2h ago

Music Oct 27: Debussy's Nocturnes premiered in full on this day (1901).

Post image
8 Upvotes

Camille Chevillard and the Lamoureux Orchestra had given the first two pieces, Nuages and Fêtes, in Paris the previous December. Sirènes was left out then because a women's chorus could not be found. On October 27, 1901, the same performers gave all three.

Debussy said he used the title in a general and, above all, decorative sense: not the usual nocturne form, but the impressions and special effects of light that the word suggests.

This piece takes me straight back to my college apartment, listening on headphones. I spent almost every night of those days listening to music until dawn, and Nocturnes is the sound of those solitary mornings when a faint light crept into the monochrome night and slowly took on color.

Nocturnes (Ernest Ansermet)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7hUxWbdHedU

*Debussy at the piano in the summer of 1893