We've had a lot of reports lately, pointing out "advertisement" or self-promotion. While these are sometimes helpful, recently these reports have been mostly missing the point. Somebody including a link to their blog/instagram/etsy/etc is not against the rules of this community as long as they follow all the other rules and appear to be engaging in good faith (for example, occasionally commenting on other posts or replying to comments on their own post). Here's some examples:
- Is a post hiding their recipe behind a link or is the recipe hidden inside a video? Those aren't following our recipe requirements.
- Are they just replying to comment questions by telling them to follow the link? That's not encouraging discussion.
- Is their post only tangentially cocktail related and doesn't include a drink and/or recipe? That's going against the intent of our recipe rule, which is trying to keep the focus of the community on MAKING cocktails and not just consuming them.
All of these are good reasons to drop a report, and that's super helpful. What's not helpful is if you drop a report when:
- They post a full recipe + drink picture, and they just happen to drop a link to an instagram/youtube/etc at the end of the post or in a comment.
- The recipe is available in text in the post or a comment, but the post also includes a short-form video of the recipe or of the drink being made.
In both of these cases, they are following our rules to the letter. Reports on these posts just because you think links shouldn't be allowed or because you don't like short-form-video content are unhelpful and verge on being report abuse (one of the primary examples reddit gives of report abuse is using the report button as a "super downvote").
______
As a sidenote, we DID change the recipe rule recently. While we have never required a picture of a cocktail, just a recipe, we ARE now also requiring a picture of a cocktail for tangential topics, such as bar setups, ice, art of cocktails, and accessories like non-edible garnishes. These posts are either prone to product promotion or can sometimes have little to do with the making of the cocktail itself, so the more stringent rule is to help keep them on topic. So for example, if you see a post about clear ice molds or countertop juicers with no cocktail included, a report would be helpful.
In general, though, thank you for everyone that submits reports. Reports are the only way to make our recipe rules work.