r/hinduism • • 12h ago

Question - General Hinduism/Catholic dialogue

6 Upvotes

Hello folks!

I am a Catholic but I enjoy dialoguing with followers of other religions and sharing our views. Hinduism is a religion which I feel I don’t know all that much about and I’m not sure how big Catholic Christianity is in India, which is of course where most Hindus live. I want to put out a post here to offer some opportunities for discussion and learning :) I did one of these on the LDS (Mormons) subreddit and it was quite successful.

I have some questions here for you guys, feel free to ask any questions you may have about Catholics, our beliefs, or our relations with Hinduism!

  1. Is Hinduism polytheistic or monotheistic? It seems, from what I have seen, that there are multiple figures in Hinduism like Shiva, Vishnu, and Ganesh. These seem to be sometimes treated as gods and sometimes as manifestations of one god?
  2. It seems that Hindus worship idols. What is the theology behind this?
  3. Is there an afterlife in Hinduism? I know there seems to be reincarnation but, once one has stopped reincarnating, is there somewhere that you go or do you just disappear? If it is the latter, why would one not want to keep reincarnating?

EDIT: A big thank you to everyone who respectfully contributed! I have had a great opportunity to learn about your beliefs and share some of my own and have had some lovely discussions with people on here! All the best to you all :-)


r/hinduism • • 15h ago

Question - General Was the Buddha avatar really a Trojan horse subversion to draw the Asuras minds away from Dharma?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
33 Upvotes

r/hinduism • • 6h ago

Hindū Darśana(s) (Philosophy) There is only one soul and our mistake of thinkign that soul(s) is countable!

0 Upvotes

few days ago shared this post

https://www.reddit.com/r/hinduism/comments/1xbdbzq/there_is_only_one_soul/

https://www.reddit.com/r/hinduism/comments/1xe1suz/there_is_only_one_soul_pt_2/

Bhagvat Geeta 2.18

The material body of the indestructible, immeasurable and eternal living entity is sure to come to an end; therefore, fight, O descendant of Bharata.

BG 2.20

For the soul there is neither birth nor death at any time. He has not come into being, does not come into being, and will not come into being. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain.

BG 2.23

The soul can never be cut to pieces by any weapon, nor burned by fire, nor moistened by water, nor withered by the wind.

BG 2.24

The soul is unbreakable and incombustible; it can neither be dampened nor dried. It is everlasting, in all places, unalterable, immutable, and primordial.

We had made a mistake of thinking that soul can be quantified and are in multiple . And this is the cause of our downfall.

Whiele in reality there is only one soul. Even our scriptures hints at that.

Try imagining anything (using it here for ease of communication) that has never made- and is there since even before creation (yeah, before creation, as creation has a beginning, but soul doesn't).

It also can't be slained/divided or differentiated and is there without changing its state. Now try imagining multiple of such things which are there together.

A question arises—how can we imagine multiple of such things?

To count anything—the basic idea is-

1- That it's somehow different from the surrounding: meaning there is some sort of division b/w it and the surrounding. Like some sort of boundary- separating it from the surrounding- does soul have a boundry? Because if it does, then it can't be immeasurable.

2- It should undergo changes- But the soul doesn't undergo any change. Even if eternity passes, soul(s) will remain same as ever. So how can there be division?

3- Historical Trajectory: An entity is discrete if it carries a unique, non-replicable trajectory through time.Does soul have such thing? because of it does the it becomes time -dependent. Is soul time dependent?

4- It occupies some space unique to itslef- Is it same for the soul?

If all these criteria don't apply to the soul, then how can it be counted? It it can't be count'es then how can we be sure that there are multiple of such entities? Maybe they are a single entity that is perceived like a multiple entity by us because of avidhya!

Edit: Using soul here only for ease of communication

Edit 2- By "preceive by us mean"- As in how we think/imagine about it- & not in as how we see it.


r/hinduism • • 17h ago

Other Does anyone else struggle with envy, anger, and loneliness in their devotional life?

3 Upvotes

its been almost two years since i fell in love with krishna and became his devotee. since then, he's become a very important part of my life. but despite all the love and connection i feel for him, ive been facing some difficulties on my spiritual journey, and i wanted to vent a little..

krishna is part of my everyday life. i read the bhagavad gita, listen to bhajans, and think about him a lot. i'd love to visit the temple more often, but i live far away, and getting there takes time and planning. i also don't have a hindu community nearby, so most of my devotional life happens alone.

recently, i had a conflict with someone that ended up preventing me from going to the temple. i felt that this person had acted intentionally and indirectly made it difficult for me to go. he's catholic, and i'm not sure whether that detail matters. i was completely devastated and cried desperately that day. in the middle of that heartbreaking crying, i even found myself thinking that krishna hated me. i prayed desperately, in tears, and it's difficult to even put into words what i felt at that moment.

throughout my teenage years, i always considered myself agnostic. but i cant remember ever wishing so much for god to exist, to truly be there and hear me, as i did that day. i'd never felt such a deep need to be heard by something divine. the temple means so much to me, and all of this happened while i was already feeling discouraged and dealing with other personal struggles, including my doubts and feelings about eating meat.

another thing i've been noticing is how much envy, anger, jealousy, and ego i can carry within myself. i love krishna, but i'm still myself, with my sense of humor, my opinions, and my flaws. i don't want devotion to mean erasing my personality or becoming someone i'm not. at the same time, i'm troubled by some of the feelings i carry, and i wonder what to do with them within my spiritual life.

i've been comparing myself to a much older friend who discovered hinduism about a month ago. she's already bought a saree and visited the temple, experiencing things i've been longing for for almost two years. i know this isn't a competition and that we're at different stages of life, but i still feel envious, and i hate comparing myself to her like this.

there's also some resentment because when i opened up to her about my struggles, my discouragement, and the situation that prevented me from visiting the temple, i felt like she didn't genuinely care. later, she came to me for advice about a romantic situation involving someone from the temple. i ended up distancing myself, partly because that hurt. maybe i also had expectations of this friendship, but it's painful to feel that someone turns to you for advice and support without necessarily showing the same interest when you're the one who needs it.

separately, there's another person from a completely different friend group, who doesn't know my friend, and vice versa. this person used to belittle my faith. i experienced religious intolerance from them, as they compared hinduism to christianity and claimed that hinduism had copied christianity. because of these experiences, i've developed a very negative view of their opinions and character.

then, out of nowhere, i found out that this person had attended ratha yatra and started posting things related to hinduism, almost as if they'd become a completely different person. it brought up a lot of anger, confusion, and envy. i don't know what really motivated this change, and i recognize that i can't know their intentions. but part of me wonders whether they're trying to impress someone or cultivate an image of being spiritual and good vibes, as if nothing that happened before had ever existed.

i think there's also something bigger behind my reaction: sometimes, i'm genuinely perplexed by what hinduism seems to be becoming in the west, or at least by the way i've seen some people relate to it. i don't know how fair this perception is, but it bothers me to see something so sacred and meaningful to me presented, in certain contexts, as an aesthetic, an identity, or a trend, especially when it comes from people who once disrespected my faith. and then i feel guilty for feeling this way.

all of this has made me wonder whether i'll ever find close friendships with other devotees. sometimes, i feel like we're so different in personality that i'd have to change who i am to fit in. i don't want to pretend to be more serene, more delicate, or more spiritual than i really am just to belong in a community.

i also feel envious of christians here in brazil. they seem to have more opportunities to go to church together, talk about christ, and share both meaningful conversations and everyday nonsense. there's a sense of community and familiarity that i deeply miss. meanwhile, i have to deal with distance and complicated logistics just to visit a temple.

sometimes, i wonder whether sanatana dharma, at least as i've experienced it so far, has more to do with solitude, meditation, and inner work than with the kind of companionship i long for. i know this is just my personal impression and doesn't necessarily represent hinduism as a whole. i just wish my spiritual life had more community, more time spent together, more people i could talk to about krishna and also about completely mundane things.

i don't think i'm a better devotee than anyone else, and i don't want to judge who belongs in hinduism based on when they discovered krishna, their appearance, or how they express their devotion. i don't want to nurture resentment either. but i can't simply switch off my feelings, and sometimes it seems that, on top of dealing with life's difficulties, i also have to deal with the guilt of not being the devotee i'd like to be.

for those of you who've struggled with envy, anger, or resentment in your devotional life, how do you deal with these feelings without considering yourselves terrible devotees? how do you reconcile your love for krishna with your own imperfections without feeling like you have to erase who you are?

and for those of you who live far away from temples, how do you cope with the isolation? have you managed to build devotional friendships despite having very different personalities??

idk...sometimes, all i really want is to feel that i'm not alone on this journey. i'd be grateful for any advice, if you feel like sharing. im genuinely asking with an open heart, and i hope to learn from your experiences.


r/hinduism • • 12h ago

Question - Beginner Why is Shiva’s throat blue? The Halahala story is darker than most retellings

3 Upvotes

Most of us know Shiva as Neelkanth, the one who drank the poison. But the older texts tell it with more detail than the usual summary.
During the churning of the ocean (Samudra Manthan), the first thing to emerge wasn’t nectar. It was Halahala, a poison so potent that devas and asuras alike feared it would end all creation. When they went to Shiva, he drank it. In the version in the Bhagavata Purana (Canto 8), Parvati’s hand on his throat stops it from going further, and that is why it turned blue.
What stands out to me is the choice. Nobody could force him to do it. He took it on so everyone else wouldn’t have to.
Which version of this story did you grow up with, and does it change between regions or texts? I’d love to hear the retellings I haven’t come across.
I covered the full story with the scripture references in a ~10 minute video here, if anyone wants it: https://youtu.be/5FkBEpL81vQ


r/hinduism • • 17h ago

Other Iam at rock bottom in my life, please help me

11 Upvotes

20M, Iam a person who has no idea about tantra🙏, so iam very sorry for posting this here but i genuinely feel that maybe spirituality can help me.

My life has been utter gutter since Covid, it began with my maternal grandparents who were everything to me passing away. Grandmother died from heart attack, i couldn't even see her last moments as she died in ICU of hospital and my grandfather was diagnosed with hodgkins lymphoma( cancer), since surgery was not possible at old age there was nothing that could be done, he too passed away within 1 yr of my grandmothers death.

My life has been chaos since then, my Father's personality suddenly changed as he was almost caught having an affair in 2025, my mother was at a very vulnerable position at that time. He has suddenly transformed into a completely rude person who judges me and my mother all the time. Verbal abuse has become common now.

I used to be topper in studies but it has faded away as if i have lost my spark in life, somehow managed to get 82% in 12th and now second dropper for NEET. Have changed coachings, found lots of problems, i have difficulty in grasping concepts, memory and so many things which i never had before. Honestly i don't know why iam no longer able to find success despite working hard or why iam facing so many problems in my life when i want to improve.

is there any kind of mantra, or any specific deity or ritual that i can do to change my life like before


r/hinduism • • 9h ago

Question - Beginner Is there anyone (besides ourselves) in Hinduism who prevents us from attaining enlightenment?

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/hinduism • • 11h ago

Question - Beginner How to deal with a bad phase and death? (22f)

10 Upvotes

I’m a 22 year old uni student. I grew up in a Hindu family outside India.

I’ve been going through an incredibly difficult phase in my life. I recently (4 days ago) failed an important exam and I now have only one attempt left to pass it. If I fail again, I would lose the opportunity to continue studying my degree subject anywhere in the country. My boyfriend and I recently broke up too (2 days ago). The relationship was hurting us both and I made mistakes .. I’m still trying to process everything that happened. And last night my grandfather passed away.

I feel as though very few things in my life have come easily to me. During my internship, I went through a particularly difficult period where I experienced a lot of racism, and the stress took a toll on my health and I developed alopecia. My hair has grown back again now.

I also had a traumatic childhood which has affected the way I connect with people. I have struggled to form and maintain friendships and I recognise that some of those unresolved experiences have also affected my romantic relationships.

I feel incredibly lonely, emotionally exhausted, and overwhelmed by everything happening at once. It feels like I barely have time to recover from one difficult experience before something else happens.

I’m trying to make sense of everything and find a way to move forward.

For those who have experienced similarly difficult phases in life, how did you get through them? How did you learn to cope with grief, loss, loneliness, and the feeling that life keeps testing you?

I don’t really have a support system. I had my boyfriend but I don’t have anyone else except him anymore. I have friends but I struggle to open up with them. I also feel like I complicate relationships. I don’t know what to do about that as well.


r/hinduism • • 12h ago

Question - General Complete contrast hanuman depiction than what we know

Thumbnail
gallery
139 Upvotes

Recently I got know how hanuman depicted in ramayana .color of his face ,hair weapon and many things are different.

What we mostly seen is a mascular man with monkey type mouth with a tail .but many vanara features are missing why they were represented clean shaved face and body .it complete misrepresentation vanaras have human type body with dense body hair different colors . hanuman body hair is golden brown with curly hair with red face as I heard.many depictions claims he doesn't weild any permanent weopen no gada

Are this are true or what we see of depicted hanuman?


r/hinduism • • 5h ago

Admiration of other Hindū denominations/scholars Once you reach a certain stage of Hinduism, academic degrees and material wealth cease to matter.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

145 Upvotes

This is the beauty of Hinduism. When you reach a certain level of spirituality, degrees, wealth, and job titles no longer matter. The search for inner peace and truth becomes more important than material success.


r/hinduism • • 23h ago

Morality/Ethics/Daily Living Ram Ram. Sharing my handwritten Ram Naam with devotion.

Post image
286 Upvotes

r/hinduism • • 13h ago

Hindū Artwork/Images Goddess Kali and Lord Shiva

Post image
348 Upvotes

​

Rakt Beej, a demon became invincible due to great powers. Goddess Durga was urged to kill him. As soon as she injured him, his blood fell on the earth and from every drop that fell a hundred demons emerged. So, she took the ferocious form of Kali, killed each demon, and drank all the blood without letting it spill to the earth.

Kali started her victory dance that caused havoc on earth and she became irrepressible.

Then the Gods pleaded to Lord Shiva to stop Kali. Once He realized the looming destruction of all, He rushed towards Kali and in a desperate final effort to calm her down He lay down at her feet while she danced trampling the uncountable corpses. Being in a state of trance she failed to realize that it was Shiva laying down and stepped on Him. The folklore further says that soon she realized Her mistake and calmed down.


r/hinduism • • 4h ago

Other Have no idea why my post got deleted...I need answers

6 Upvotes

Visited Kumortuli today and posted some pictures I clicked of Goddess idols being made...shared my experiences n all...was being completely respectful and sharing how I'm excited for the upcoming Kali Puja. And yea the post got deleted. Was it because I posted photos of Kali while Naked?

It was Kali...the naked Godess in herself, Gosh wtf is this sub? Is it even hinduism with this moderation standard?

And even if it was done to ensure that someone from other faiths don't mock us, wtf kind of a moderation tactic is this? If someone does that u take action against that specific acc, not on OP for posting it. It was nothing wrong...was completely fine for a 'Hinduism' subreddit.

Wtf is this sub becoming? Are we so scared that we can't even post Maa Kali (that too the post was removed by the moderator perhaps)...or is this some kind of Moral policing?

Atp rename the sub into something else. The action suggests that either we're very coward or absolute Moral polices. Nothing in between.


r/hinduism • • 5h ago

Question - General Can I be someone who loves God and feels genuine connection to them but doesn’t like societal norms that’s attached to religion?

3 Upvotes

I really feel connected to Lord Krishna and Durga Maa and I feel so much energy when I listen to storams and slokas. But at the same time I don’t want to call myself religious because for the starters I’m not and I don’t like all the misogyny and performative stuffs that’s attached to the religion. Like people being hateful and judgemental and justifying wrongdoings in name of religion.

So what does that make me? A devotee? An agonist?


r/hinduism • • 5h ago

Question - Beginner How to start worshipping shiva

5 Upvotes

I am 16 male from kerala, and i am going through one of the worst phase of my life and i have been diagnosed with hypothyroidism. I am not sure if its permanent thyroid or not, if its permanent the chances of being medically fit in NDA medicals are very low.I don’t have anyone to express my feelings. I wanted to know how to worship shiva.I wanted to pray that its only a temporary thyroid and not a permanent one.


r/hinduism • • 6h ago

Mantra/Śloka/Stotra(m) The Indra Stotra composed by Kadru

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

I bow to thee, thou Lord of all the Gods! I bow to thee, thou slayer of Vritra! I bow to thee, thou slayer of Namuchi! O thou of a thousand eyes, lord of Sachi! By thy showers, be thou the protector of the snakes scorched by the Sun. O thou best of the deities, thou art our great protector. O Purandara, thou art able to grant rain in torrents. Thou art wind, the clouds, fire, and the lightning of the skies. Thou art the propeller of the clouds, and hast been called the great cloud (i.e., that which will darken the universe at the end of Yuga). Thou art the fierce and incomparable thunder, and the roaring clouds. Thou art the Creator of the worlds and their Destroyer.

Thou art unconquered. Thou art the light of all creatures, Aditya, Vibhavasu, and the wonderful elements. Thou art the ruler of all the Gods. Thou art Vishnu. Thou hast a thousand eyes. Thou art God, and the final resource.

Thou art, O God, all ambrosia, and the most adored Soma. Thou art the moment, the lunar day, the bala (minute), thou art the kshana (4 minutes). Thou art the lighted fortnight, and also the dark fortnight. Thou art kala, thou kashtha, and thou Truti. Thou art the year, the seasons, the months, the nights, and the days.

Thou art the fair Earth with her mountains and forests. Thou art also the firmament, resplendent with the Sun. Thou art the great Ocean with heaving billows and abounding with whales, swallowers of whales, and makaras, and various fishes. Thou art of great renown, always adored by the wise and by the great Rishis with minds rapt in contemplation.

Thou drinkest, for the good of all creatures, the Soma juice in sacrifices and the clarified butter offered with sacred invocation.

Thou art always worshipped at sacrifices by Brahmins moved by desire of fruit. O thou of incomparable mass of strength, thou art sung in the Vedas and Vedangas. It is for that reason that learned Brahmins bent upon performing sacrifices, study the Vedas with every care.


r/hinduism • • 9h ago

Question - General Can I observe my first Karwa Chauth in 2026 despite Shukra Asta? Married for 5 years but never fasted before.

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I have a few questions about Karwa Chauth and would really appreciate some guidance, especially from people who are familiar with the traditions.
A little background:
My community doesn’t traditionally celebrate Karwa Chauth, so I never really thought about observing it before.
However, this year, my husband and I went through an emotional roller coaster. We faced some of the toughest situations of our lives, and at times, our marriage was really tested.
But through everything, we stood by each other. Our faith in God grew stronger, and somehow, our marriage became even stronger than before.
This experience made me realize how incredibly blessed I am to have my husband. I genuinely don’t think I could have found a better person to share my life with. He’s not perfect, but he fits perfectly into the puzzle of my life. ❤️
That’s why I want to observe Karwa Chauth this year.
For me, it’s not just about following a religious tradition. It’s my way of expressing love and gratitude, and praying for his health, happiness, and long life.
I don’t know whether fasting can actually extend someone’s lifespan, but regardless, I would love to dedicate this day to praying for his well-being.
Now, here’s where I’m confused.
I recently heard that Karwa Chauth in 2026 falls during Shukra Asta, and that women shouldn’t start observing the vrat for the first time during this period.
My husband and I have been married for five years, so I’m not a newlywed. However, this would be my very first Karwa Chauth vrat.
My questions are:
Does the restriction apply only to newly married women, or to anyone observing Karwa Chauth for the first time?
Is it okay for me to start the vrat this year despite Shukra Asta?
According to your family’s or community’s beliefs, what are the consequences, if any, of starting during this period?


r/hinduism • • 13h ago

Hindū Festival देवर्षि नारद एवं रत्नाकर डाकू (वाल्मीकि जी) का संवाद

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

​

वाल्मीकि जयंती की शुभकामनाएं 🙏


r/hinduism • • 19h ago

Hindū Darśana(s) (Philosophy) Visiting Shani Shingnapur? A few things to keep in mind to avoid scams and have a peaceful darshan

5 Upvotes

​

I frequently visit Shani Shingnapur and have immense faith in Lord Shani. I just wanted to share a few things I’ve noticed during my visits so that others can avoid unnecessary hassles and have a peaceful darshan.

  1. Beware of people following you on bikes

As soon as you start entering from the main highway, you may notice people waiting around and following you on their bikes, asking you to pull over. They usually have stalls selling pooja items and want you to buy from them.

Just wave them off through your rear-view mirror or politely tell them you aren’t interested. They usually leave immediately. Sometimes, police personnel are present and these people don’t follow you, but on my recent visit, they were still doing it despite the police presence.

  1. Don’t get confused by the ₹5 receipt and parking claims

After entering Shani Shingnapur, you’ll have to pay ₹5 to the Gram Panchayat. A little further ahead, some people may block your way and tell you that showing this receipt will get you free parking.

Don’t get pressured into stopping or following their directions. Stay calm and continue towards the temple. There is a government parking area right in front of the temple, which charges ₹20. I prefer parking there.

  1. You don’t need to buy every pooja item

In my experience, oil is the main offering you need for Lord Shani. Flowers, coconuts and other items sold along the way may not be accepted for the ritual and can end up being recycled back to the stalls.

My suggestion would be to buy mustard oil or sunflower oil from your own town before travelling, rather than feeling pressured to purchase everything at the stalls near the temple.

  1. The ₹500 donation receipt

If you wish to offer oil to the deity yourself, ask the temple authorities about the ₹500 donation receipt and the associated access to the foyer. Please confirm the current procedure and charges with the official temple staff when you arrive.

  1. Make the darshan about faith, not your phone

This is a personal request: instead of spending too much time recording photos and videos, try to spend a few moments being grateful, reflecting on your actions and taking accountability for the things you’ve done.

I’ve seen people travel from very far away to visit this sacred place. It would be a shame for their experience to be spoiled by people trying to make a quick buck.

I’m sharing this with respect for the place and everyone’s faith, not to discourage anyone from visiting. Shani Shingnapur is a place of immense significance for many of us, and a little awareness can help make the visit smoother.

Jai Shani Dev! 🙏🪔

Hope this helps fellow devotees visiting Shani Shingnapur.


r/hinduism • • 19h ago

Question - General My relationship with Krishna

5 Upvotes

Hello, I want to get people’s ideas on how they improve their relationship with gods such as Krishna. For about the first 12-13 years of my life, I had a great relationship with Krishna. I regarded him as my friend and guardian. Soon, I fell into sins which I don’t want to mention, and felt my relationship with Krishna slowly slipping away. Over the past four years, I have neglected him and now when i see him and want to talk to him, have a good talk and relaxation with him about life, he is absent from mine like how I was absent from his 😢. The feeling is hard to describe. The best way I can put it is like writing with a blunt pencil. You still write, but when you do you can’t do it properly. My devotion is like that now. When I used to repent, i used to cry and do so with upmost devotion. Now, though, i just shove my feelings under a rug (“teen angst” my parents call it). Now, my life has no friends. I am being such a bad person to everyone it makes me want to cry. But then again, for some reason, I can’t. I can’t get my feelings out and feel bad. I can’t help but feel as though Krishna is punishing me for my sins and neglectment. No matter what I do I can’t get back to him. I can’t feel the devotion, I can’t feel the repenting feeling. I really don’t know where to start and just want to end up happy. I want to have friends, I want to be back together with Krishna in my heart fully. My brain isn’t letting me love him or even forgive myself for my sins. I would appreciate any advice from anyone. If you have gone through this, please tell me how you went through this as I feel extremely bleak now. Thank you.