r/modmailfail • u/SeasDiver • 5h ago
So close and yet so far
We allow educational (but not business) surveys if reviewed/approved in advance. Oh well...
r/modmailfail • u/SeasDiver • 5h ago
We allow educational (but not business) surveys if reviewed/approved in advance. Oh well...
r/modmailfail • u/FyrestarOmega • 3h ago
Context: user posts about being disappointed that the eye candy keeps getting voted out in a reality show and wants that opinion heard as a full-fledged post, imbilcilic moderators be damned!
r/modmailfail • u/cnycompguy • 16h ago
Rule 1 ban for stating men that prefer cats to dogs are feminine.
r/modmailfail • u/PoopyMcpants • 1d ago
r/modmailfail • u/CatAteRoger • 1d ago
We have rules for a reason and if they didn’t do what they did we’d never have perm banned to start with, time does not alter what is done nor change the severity.
r/modmailfail • u/ikandi • 2d ago
All because he didn’t have enough karma.
Although I’m devastated to have lost the trust of such a valuable member 😭💀.
r/modmailfail • u/cnycompguy • 2d ago
It started as a 3 day ban for rule 1 (subreddit rule 1 is the same as sitewide rule 1, for ease of reference)
r/modmailfail • u/astralwish1 • 2d ago
1.1-1.2 is one user, 2.1-2.4 is another user.
Guess what caused these conversations? If you guessed yet another political ad post, you win another freeze peach!
I’m so sick of this election cycle. November can’t come soon enough.
r/modmailfail • u/Lausannea • 3d ago
\sips tea** They were banned right after that!
r/modmailfail • u/ChimpyChompies • 3d ago
r/modmailfail • u/Royal_Acanthaceae693 • 4d ago
The general sub removal reason for this sort of thing is: "This is a nice place. If you can't act like a civilized human being, you can't be here.
We do not allow:
Being a jerk. This includes racism, misogyny, misandry, misgendering, anti LGBTQ+, ageism, etc....
General assholery. If you're at the end of the list and asking what rule you broke, yeah, it's this one."
It's always funny which part of this people decide to complain about.
r/modmailfail • u/MaximumJones • 4d ago
Just more ammo for adding to the MCOC of whining sub I guess. 🤷♀️
r/modmailfail • u/ProudnotLoud • 5d ago
r/modmailfail • u/StJmagistra • 5d ago
This was his response after a one day ban for not following the subreddit rules. Welcome to Reddit, my friend.
r/modmailfail • u/JJStone_95 • 7d ago
r/modmailfail • u/MaximumJones • 8d ago
r/modmailfail • u/Furryb0nes • 7d ago
User banned for posting a gif that encouraged beating a man discovered to be gay.
r/modmailfail • u/Furryb0nes • 9d ago
r/modmailfail • u/ohhyouknow • 9d ago
We archived a bunch of things that aren’t pictured here, so this isn’t every message we got like this today.
A day or two ago I posted a user who had been banned across several subreddits for a comment on one subreddit. I did not ban them in the others until they appealed their original ban like an ass. Some mods here took issue with that.
I am the top moderator or the defacto top moderator in most of these subreddits. Either I am the top moderator, or, I manage the subreddits in the capacity of a top moderator under now inactive top moderators who trust me to manage the subreddits in their place, and not kick them from the teams due to their inactivity.
These subreddits host very similar content and sometimes a single video can be posted across all of them and I am responsible for making sure the same post gets moderated across several supermassive subreddits.
If a person leaves a bigoted comment in one of these subreddits, they will absolutely leave one in one of the other ones, I would know, I mod all of these subreddits and they always do.
A few what looked like fairly experienced moderators had a problem with me banning people across several subreddits. One of them even said that doing so violated the mod code of conduct, quoting the old mod guide, which were never rules, they were only suggestions, a guide if you will.
Sorry not sorry but this is what people who leave horrible comments are like. Some of these message chains have over a dozen spammed bigoted and threatening messages when you expand them. One of them told us they hoped we would watch our children die in our arms.
I didn’t find those mods very cash money for their criticisms. You won’t ever make me feel badly for banning people like this from every subreddit I moderate. Grateful for the mods of this subreddit who are always on top of comments like that. 🙏
/endrant