I've been slowly but surely making my way through all the needles! I still am short a couple that I'm having trouble finding in stock, but I've collected nearly every needle I'm going to review.
Purpose of this review: I have corrosive skin that eats through metal plating faster than that one time I was on a date at On the Border (rip) and he ate his burrito so quickly even the waiter was like "wow." Needles are disposable, but I want to find the ones that last the longest for me.
Disclaimer 1: Nobody has the same chemical makeup, so what works for me may not work for you and vice versa. This is intended to help give people with similar struggles a starting point and a place for conversation if I'm the oddball here.
Disclaimer 2: All needles are tested with my specific stitching habits. I'm not the fastest stitcher, nor am I consistent with washing my hands before I stitch, nor are my numbers 100% accurate. Sometimes I forget to count a couple frogged stitches. I try to be as accurate as possible, but I'm doing this alongside my hobby, not as a true scientific experiment.
Results (first 5 needles):
- EdMar: 2308 -- I'm going to retest this one, it wore really unevenly, sometimes I could feel it and sometimes I couldn't, so I stopped using it after visible wear on the shaft. Had a sharpish tip with an eye that was easy to thread, though burrs had formed by the end making it much harder.
- JIGEGE (Amazon brand): 1158 -- Slightly more dull than the EdMar but the eye was identical. I did not enjoy stitching with this one, it felt like there was a coating on it from the beginning that created a tiny bit of friction. It also looked like the needle was pitting rather than the plating wearing off. Came with 100 needles though, so I'll have backups for life.
- Sullivan's Ball Tip: 1559 -- This has been my favorite to stitch with so far because of it's shape. I was going so fast and my thread almost never split! It felt a little bigger than the others, kind of between a 26 and 28. When the silver plating wore off I could smell it immediately, and it was very rough to pass through.
- John James (regular): 1832 -- Sharper than the others I've tested so far, easy enough to thread. It was going strong until very suddenly it wasn't, getting rough and smelly all at once.
- John James (gold): 699 -- I knew this wouldn't last and I was so right. The eye was also narrower than the regular John James and was a pain to thread.
Currently stitching with the John James platinum plated. I'll update again after I've gone through 5 more needles!
Full needles list: DMC (both 2025 and pre), John James (nickel, gold, and platinum), Mary Arden, Sullivan's Ball Tip, Cross Stitch Guild gold plated, Kimberly's, EdMar, JIGEGE, Bohin, Pony Black (black, white, and red eye), Colonial petites (nickel and gold plated), and Lori Holt. I will not be testing Piecemakers.
Let me know if there are any other brands I need to include! The only criteria are they must be size 28 and I can get them in the US (I'm willing to pay tariff fees, for science)