I matched with a girl on Hinge a few weeks ago, and I'm genuinely confused about this situation.
For some background, she was always pretty inconsistent with messaging on Hinge. She'd respond enthusiastically and then disappear for days or even weeks. I'd occasionally double-text, and she'd eventually come back and apologize, saying she sometimes takes breaks from the app.
Last Friday, she actually suggested exchanging numbers, and we spontaneously decided to meet for drinks that same night.
The date was honestly one of the best first dates I've had in a long time.
We had amazing conversation, tons of flirting, physical affection, and ended up kissing quite a bit. She was asking lots of questions about me, and everything felt incredibly natural.
What really stood out was how frequently SHE brought up seeing me again.
Throughout the date, she'd find ways to suggest future activities together without me even bringing them up.
For example, I mentioned that I go to the gym regularly, and she immediately said something along the lines of, "I'd love to come with you sometime if you ever need a gym partner."
When we talked about cooking, she said she'd love to try my cooking. When I mentioned some of my favorite places, she wanted me to take her. She also brought up other activities we could do together.
These weren't things I was suggesting and she was politely agreeing to. She was volunteering these ideas throughout the night.
At one point, I suggested getting together again later the following week, and she literally said, "You really want to wait that long to see me again?"
She then went through her schedule and told me which nights she was available, clearly expressing that she wanted to see me sooner.
We ended up making dinner plans for Sunday, just two days after our first date.
I dropped her off Friday night, and we kissed goodbye. Everything seemed great.
Then things got weird.
I texted her Saturday morning and didn't hear back.
On Sunday, I texted to confirm our 7:30 dinner reservation. She responded, saying she'd forgotten about a baby shower and had a busy day. She mentioned she'd call me after work.
I responded positively and said we could figure something out.
She never called.
I followed up later that evening, mentioning I'd canceled the reservation but would still love to see her and asking about rescheduling.
No response, and now it's Monday afternoon.
I'm genuinely confused because her interest Friday night seemed incredibly obvious. She wasn't just agreeing to another date. She was actively suggesting things we should do together, volunteering her availability, and expressing that she wanted to see me again ASAP.
I understand that sometimes people lose interest after a first date, but the contrast between Friday and now is pretty extreme.
I'm also wondering whether this is simply her communication style, considering she was similarly inconsistent on Hinge before we met.
I really liked this girl and would love to see her again, but I also don't want to keep chasing someone who isn't interested.
My questions:
- Would you interpret this as a loss of interest, or could she genuinely just be a terrible communicator?
- Is it worth sending one more text asking if she's available Tuesday or Thursday?
- Would calling her be too much, considering we've never spoken on the phone?
- Has anyone experienced something similar where the person eventually came back around?
I know the obvious advice is probably to move on, but the chemistry was strong enough that I'm hesitant to give up after one weekend.
Curious what others would do.