Hey everyone, I need a place to vent and get some outside perspective on a situation that has completely turned my life upside down over the last few months. It is a very long post so I apologize in advance.
Here are the people involved.
Me (29 M)
A (21 TF) My best friend
L (24 TM) A's partner and my crush
I need to point out that A and L are polyamorous. Also, so L can stay in this country A and L got married in March of this year as well, but they maintained their poly arrangement.
āTo give context, I was part of a close group dynamic with two people: A, who was my absolute best friend, and L, who is Aās partner. I met A at work and we developed a strong friendship pretty quickly.
Basically because she didn't have a place to live for the next month from when we met I offered one of the spare rooms in the apartment where I was living so she can move in temporarily while she looked for a place (this was literally in our first conversation) and she accepted. (I know it could have gone pretty bad for both of us because we didn't know each other at all but im glad it turned out fine) From that point onwards we got close pretty quickly and eventually she moved out like 3 monthts after she moved in, somewhere in August of last year. In December of last year, L who was the long distance relationship of A, moved to the city and they started living together. Because A and me were so close, I was also there the day that L arrived at the city and I met him there.
Moving on to July of this year, my landlord decided to end the contract for internet.(Because of my contract, I couldn't just go and get another provider without the approval from my landlord which he never gave me when I asked)
I needed internet to work and play videogames. So I started going to A and L's place almost daily. Over time, I developed strong romantic feelings for L. It grew naturally because whenever I went over, we spent hours talking. The conversations and jokes moved seamlessly and I felt like we were bonding pretty quickly. If I'm honest it kinda felt like I already knew him from all my life because we always had stuff to talk about and we both got enthusiastic for listening to the other person talk about our interests and future hopes.
Before anything started I had a talk with A telling her that I like L but if she is not comfortable with that or has any objections I will stop it immediately and it will never be spoken again. She assured me that she was actually happy about thst and that I had her full support and that it would be amazing because the three of us will spend a lot more time together.
Then, with A's help, I did in fact tell L that I liked him and wanted to take him out on a date to see where things head out, this was around mid August, At this time he had a medical condition with his wisdom tooth that hurt a lot and constantly so he basically said that he would rather have that fixed before he would give me an answer, it was not a yes nor a no, it was a rain check for later. But from that point on I did start treating him like someone I liked by bringing him gifts and spending even more time talking with him and trying to learn about him so I knew the things he liked. I will admit that from this point on and while our connection grew stronger every day I started acting like I had the yes on the date already guaranteed and it was just a matter of time before we go out.
Time moved on with that renewed dynamic for a while and to be honest things seemed to be going somewhat fine. I had a couple of issues with this dynamic because it was new to me and also because I have some traumas from my past but we agreed that we will always keep a proper communication between the 3 of us so any and all issues we have will be solved promptly before they grew larger.
Then it came the third week of september. The dentist L went to was really bad and even though he was in pain they wanted to do the extraction until November. On the same day, L and I had an argument for something else as well. So in my mind I came to 3 conclusions that day
1) I cared enough about L to want him to not be in pain any longer
2) I wanted to apologize for the argument that we had and
3) I didn't want to wait until November for an answer.
So I checked with all my contacts and found a dentist a hundred times better than the previous one, and as a surprise I scheduled an appointment with him for the next day for L. I didn't tell L about the plan to schedule it because I surprised him with that in that same afternoon. In long story short there, they checked him out, on the next day, and realized the problem and scheduled an extraction for the next week. So that day was only the check up and nothing more.
After the appointment, A went to work and I stayed with L all the afternoon and part of the night. Lets say from 14:00 until 22:00. It was amazing, we talked a lot, we watched videos, we ordered pizza. The conversation never stalled. To be honest it was amazing. And when I left I even sent him a text saying that it was an amazing afternoon and 8 hours felt like 5 minutes and he agreed that it was amazing hanging out with me and that time flew by us pretty quickly.
After that going into the weekend I felt the shift in energy pretty quickly because neither A or L texted me or invited me to hang out with them over the weekend at their house like they usually do and when I texted I got a 1 or 2 words answer back from them, if they answered at all. So i decided on Monday I would take the same route to work as A and try to talk to her.
Things completely exploded after that conversation with A. Out of nowhere, A made an implication that my presence or actions could somehow pose a physical threat or danger to L. This hit me immensely hardānot only because it was completely untrue and uncharacteristic of who I am (and she knew it by the way in which we met), but because it directly triggered deep past trauma I carry regarding what has happened to me and how I am perceived and treated by people I care about.
āThe fallout was swift and devastating:
āL completely blocked me on everything following that conversation, cutting off communication without giving me a real chance to talk through things directly with him or even explain exactly where I went wrong or argue with me (like he did before) to show me where i was going wrong and work from there.
āA and my friendship became deeply strained which deeply hurts me given how close we were.
āEventually, A and I had a very long meeting to try to address the fractures and see if our friendship could be salvaged. She admitted that she didn't realize that she actually implied that I would ever be a danger to L and that she truly believes that I am not that kind of person and that she was sorry for even unknowingly suggesting that I could be any danger to L in any context at all.
From what I could gather from conversations with A apparently some of my mistakes are
1) Surprising L with the dentist appointment: They felt it crossed a boundary and was a betrayal of trust, even though they acknowledged it ultimately helped L get care that he desperately needed. L felt like I was doing that just to try to hurry up his decision (which I will admit it was in part that) instead of me coming from a place of deep care for his wellbeing (which was mostly that)
2) Staying 8 hours that afternoon: Apparently L wanted me to leave earlier but never expressed it to meādirectly or indirectly. Had he said anything, I would have respected his boundaries immediately and left. (It would have hurt but I would have left anyway)
3) Offering to accompany them to his extraction procedure: I offered to join A in supporting L during his procedure because I cared about him, but it was seen as overstepping.
4) A was angry that because I hanged out with L all that afternoon she could not talk with him and blamed me for it.
āThe situation has left me in a really dark and painful place. Iāve had to grieve the abrupt loss of L from my life while simultaneously dealing with the deep rupture in my friendship with A. Even when trying to repair things with A, the ghost of what happened with L and the unfair way I was characterized hangs over everything. I constantly struggle with a desire for closure, lingering feelings for L, and the painful realization that the deep trust we all shared might be gone forever.
āIām trying my best to set healthy boundaries, protect my own peace, and process this grief, but some days it feels overwhelming.
How do I manage a strained friendship with my best friend when the ghost of this fallout is still so fresh?
Is it healthier to step back entirely, or are there ways to navigate this distance while processing the loss of L?
How can I process the pain of being abruptly cut off by someone I cared about while protecting my own mental health?
Any advice on letting go of the need for an explanation when communication is completely closed off?
Is it healthy of me to still keep a hope alive that I can get back?
I know I made some very massive mistakes but I have never felt so heartbroken before for any past relationships. Not sure how to move on.
TL;DR: I (M) was in a polyamorous dynamic with my best friend, "A" (TF), and her partner/husband, "L" (TM). With A's blessing, I confessed romantic feelings for L, and we had an open, cautious setup while L dealt with a painful medical condition. I tried to help L by surprising him with a dentist appointment and spending 8 hours hanging out, but it backfired. A suddenly implied I could pose a danger to Lātriggering my past traumaāand L completely blocked me without communication. A, later apologized for the phrasing, but my feelings for L, the abrupt loss of contact, and the ruined trust have left me devastated.